Romeo and juliet movie comparison chart freebooksummary. There is no mention of rosaline at all and there wont be. In both the play and the movie, balthasar goes to mantua to tell romeo that juliet is laid low in her kindreds vault shakespeare 5. Considered as one of the greatest love stories of all time, william shakespeares romeo and juliet is a timeless literary classic and remains perhaps the most appreciated piece of literature in all of history. David ansen, film critic, describes it as alternately enrapturing and exhausting, brilliant and gliba romeo and juliet more for the eyes than the ears. In the modernized version there is no prologue to this scene and juliet is actually never in the balcony. Films comparison from their representation of characters to their use of language, zefirelli and luhrmann take two very different approaches to shakespeares second most famous theatrical work. Difference between romeo and juliet the book and the movie. Romeo and juliet julia essig preuniversity paper didactics english miscellaneous publish your bachelors or. In franco zeffirellis 1968 version of romeo and juliet, is a traditional adaptation of shakespeares original romeo and juliet, with some variations. Similarities and differences between romeo and juliet play and movie. But a lot changed between the original play and the film. Romeo and juliet balcony scene comparison posts by mahruf. Depends which new and old movies you are talking about.
Difference between romeo and juliet movie and movie. Romeo and juliet act v scene iii directors purpose and interpretation does it add or take away. The two are family run corporations that are against each other. Mar 21, 2020 despite the circumstances surrounding its conception being rather hazy, romeo and juliet has endured for an exceptionally long time. I dont recall romeo doing acid in the play mercutio was a lot creepier in the movie personal opinion in the movie, juliet wakes up immediately after romeo has taken the poison and they have one last exchange, but that did not happen in the play. Comparison between novel and the movie of romeo and juliet essay sample in present paper im going to compare two works of art. Many times the play by william shakespeare is compared to the movie produced by baz luhrman. The book romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is about two opposing households with much hatred for each other. The 20 cinematic adaptation of romeo and juliet got a few things right, but it mostly missed the mark. Enter romeo, mercutio, benvolio, with five or six other maskers. The movie is set in modern day, not the day that it was written.
William shakespeare is said to have adapted the play at some point between 1591 and 1595 based on a story by arthur brooke in 1562, and since then, it has been adapted into just about everything you can imagine. Similarities between romeo and juliet book and luhrman. There have been at least a dozen movies made of romeo and juliet. Balthasar is unaware of the fake suicide and believes that juliet is truly dead.
They discover their lover is their enemy through decades of family feuds. But first i will tell you the story about romeo and juliet, and later i will go into more details like language, differences in content and other distinctions between the film and the drama. Asked in movies, romeo and juliet, drama movies, the difference between what are the differences between the movie and the book titled romeo and juliet. This play has been converted into its intended style many times in the past, the earliest version in 1968 was directed by franco zeffirelli, the latest film in 1996 by baz luhrmann. Shakespeares romeo and juliet is a play based on love, hate, tragedy and sacrifice. Differences between the play romeo and juliet and the movie. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet movies. Key differences between romeo and juliet play and movie conclusion. The characters of romeo and juliet were the same in both the movie and the book. Yes, the play is very good as well as the movie, but the play has its great parts, and its. Similarities and differences between romeo and juliet play. William shakespeares romeo and juliet is a cherished piece of literature that has been remade into movies many times throughout history. For instance movies are mostly easier to understand then books though the plots may have slight differences. Romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is a loved classic.
What are the differences between the romeo and juliet movie and book. In both the movie and the play tybalt, juliets cousin, did not get along with mercutio, romeos dear friend. There are many differences between the play and the movie of romeo and juliet. The play did a better job in the story because it gives the detail needed to imagine everything, and once it is imagined nothing can ever compare. As soon as the film opens, it becomes obvious they changed the prologue. Compare and contrast romeo and juliet play and movie. Romeo and juliet movie comparison 2714 words 11 pages. Differences between the play romeo and juliet and the. Compare and contrast romeo and juliet play and movie writework. The party itself took time with the dance, romeo laying his eyes upon juliet, and their kissing scene. Over the years it has been remade into movies, ballets and childrens books. Movie comparison romeo and juliet essay example for.
Although the movie romeo and juliet directed by baz luhrmann has the same basic elements as shakespeares romeo and juliet, there are several differences that exist amongst them. The fighters have guns in the movie, when in the play they have swords. Most always when movies are compared to the books, the books are better, but not quite in this case. William shakespeares romeo and juliet although the story of romeo and juliet is over 500 years old, it is as relevant and appealing today as it was when first performed. However, once characters start behaving radically different, once. There are many differences between this film and the play. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet movies shakespeares romeo and juliet is a play based on love, hate, tragedy and sacrifice. Yes, the play is very good as well as the movie, but the play has its great parts. Jul 01, 2012 the fighters have guns in the movie, when in the play they have swords. Comparison between novel and the movie of romeo and juliet. One of the major differences is that the book takes place in.
Romeo was now standing between his new cousin and his long time dear friend. Romeo and juliet differences between movie and book. Shakespeare vs luhrmann vs carlei the infamous, tragic deaths of shakespeares starcrossed lovers romeo of montague and juliet capulet have been capturing the hearts of audiences of many centuries, eliciting fairly highbudget adaptations even in the 1990s and 2000s. Two movies were made based on the classic love story, romeo and juliet. Juliet uses romeo s handgun to shoot herself in the head. While the 1968 classical version of shakespeares romeo and juliet should be appreciated, the modern version portrays the. In the 1996 version, it is quite clear that romeo spends the night in juliet s room and leaves the next morning. In order for me to comment on both versions of romeo and juliet i will compare the opening shots, the way the main characters are introduced and the types of music and costumes used in each version. The play focuses on romantic love, where romeo and juliet experience love at first sight. The capulet and montague parents dont have first names in. Its impossible to know which one youre referring to. The enduring tale of love between two star crossd lovers has been told, acted, and read countless times since its original debut. Romeo and juliet movie vs book why you might prefer one over another. Romeo and juliet movie comparison essay 2469 words free essay.
It tells the story of two starcrossed lovers as they try to find a place in the world together without dealing with the wrath of heir families rivalry. The differences between romeo and juliet in shakespeares play by the same name make their relationship work in that each supports the other and the relationship is allowed to grow at the start. Last night i watched romeo and juliet 20 film directed by carlo carlei. In the 1996 movie the tragedy of romeo and juliet by baz luhrman, there are some major differences between his version and the book romeo and juliet by william shakespeare. The 1968 version and the controversial 1996 version give different perspectives of shakespeares famous play. Baz luhrmann directed the 1996 version, also known as the mtv romeo juliet. Apr 20, 20 romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is a loved classic. Romeo goes to the capulet crypt to find juliet s body and encounters paris there.
Similarities between romeo and juliet book and luhrman movie. Zeffirellis versions of romeo and juliet this essay will compare two versions of romeo and juliet directed by baz luhrmann and franco zeffirelli. In this book, lehmann conducts a close study of the film adaptations of romeo and juliet to analyze the relationship between them and the original text. It has been retold many different times in both written and film text and it is effective and timeless throughout the use of many techniques. Significant movies have been made of romeo and juliet in 1936, 1955, 1968, 1996 and 20. Romeo and juliet, the dramatic love story everyone knows. It is amazing how shakespeares play romeo and juliet written centuries ago can be better than franco zefferellis movie production of romeo and juliet, which had much better technology to work with only decades ago. This article will compare and contrast between the play itself and two famous romeo and juliet movies. While watching the latest version i thought a lot about the 1968 version which is similar to the 20 film, the 20 film is a. Comparing zeffirelli and luhrmanns versions of romeo and.
There are many differences and similarities between luhrmanns 1996 version of romeo and juliet, and zeferellis 1968 version. There have been numerous movies made of romeo and juliet and all of them like all stage plays make some alterations from the script. Romeo and juliet movie and book comparison essaysshakespeares romeo and juliet is the most famous love story to date. In the movie the capulets and the montagues are warring families in italy. Baz luhrmann and franco zefirelli are two directors who. Baz luhrmanns kaleidoscopic film adaptation of romeo and juliet, while often leaving much to be desired from the two main actors in the way of delivery, presents a fascinating modern interpretation of the 16th century drama. In the play, he does not when juliet is trying to find out who he is, she asks the nurse whats he that follows there, that would not dance. It depends which movie and, for that matter, which book. Romeo and juliet movie comparison paper campbell2015. In the movie when juliet finds romeo dead she takes his dagger and commits suicide by stabbing herself in the chest. Book often times people say that william shakespeare was and still is a legend.
The dead dagger verona italy pistol verona beach new york in the play. Despite the circumstances surrounding its conception being rather hazy, romeo and juliet has endured for an exceptionally long time. Differences the book vs movie juliet romeo answers. With taking good time the movie felt legit, there was more of a classic feeling. Essay about text vs movie romeo and juliet 741 words. Romeo and juliet movie comparison essay 650 words bartleby. Romeo and juliet differences between movie and book free essays. The timeless tale of romeo and juliet has been told again and again. Three main points of interest for the comparison in these two scenes are how romeo acts during the scene, the setting of the scene, and the position of romeo and juliet. Tybalt and mercutio were fighting, and it got out of hand just as romeo appeared. Shelby campbell romeo and juliet is a tragic play written by the very famous william shakespeare. One major difference between the play and the movie occurs in mood.
The first movie was made in 1968 and the second was a much more modern remake of the classic tale which was made in 1996. The 1968 version of romeo and juliet, directed by franco zeffirelli, is set to a more traditional idea. Romeo and juliet movie vs book essay example graduateway. Romeo and juliets movies differences and similarities. This famous line has come from a play, which has been made into a movie many times. Because balthasar reaches romeo before friar lawrence can get word to him, the love between romeo and juliet is doomed. How do the differences between romeo and juliet define their. Although dated, the story of romeo and juliet still holds great appeal and relevance to todays society, despite the differences in morals and values between william. Unfortunately, juliet, this is not always the case. One part is the scene with apothecary when romeo is. In both the movie and the play tybalt, juliet s cousin, did not get along with mercutio, romeo s dear friend. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet.
I think it adds to the original purpose bacause watching it instead of just reading the story really lets you see how they loved each. The last night between romeo and juliet was not obvious in zefferellis version, but romeo is leaving juliet s chamber in the morning. Though romeo and juliet the movie is good, it is still missing many good parts. In the first scene, the audience is introduced to the hatred between the two feuding families, and both directors portray this in similar and different ways.